Something’s stirring across Africa. In living rooms from Accra to Abuja, in beer bars in Nairobi, over Eworkple and Aborvi tadi in Anlo Afiadenyigba, people are talking. Not whispering anymore. Actually talking.
The question? If our men are going to cheat anyway, shouldn’t we just let them marry two wives properly?
It sounds mad at first. But hear them out.
When the Side Chick Brings More Than Drama
Madam Efua’s hands still shake when she tells the story. Forty-two years old, successful businesswoman, thought she had a solid marriage.
“I didn’t know about the other women. Three of them. Maybe four.” She pauses, looks away. “I found out when he gave me an infection. Can you imagine? If he’d just told me he wanted another wife, at least I would have known what I was dealing with.”
The nurses and doctors will tell you, most STIs they’re treating? Not coming from polygamous homes. They’re coming from married men with girlfriends. Secret ones. The ones who swear to their wives they’re faithful while maintaining two, three lovers on the side.
Kofi, a farmer from Central Region, doesn’t even try to sugarcoat it: “Look, men like women. We can pretend all day, but it’s the truth. So why not let a man who can manage it take two wives openly? He stays faithful to both. Better than all this sneaking around, bringing diseases home.”
You might not like what he’s saying. But he’s not alone in thinking it. The West Taught Us Monogamy. But Did They Mean It?
Here’s where it gets interesting.
People are starting to ask: Why are we so quick to copy Western relationship models when the West itself has moved beyond traditional monogamy? Open relationships, polyamory, “it’s complicated”—all acceptable there now.
“They can try ten different relationship styles and call it modern,” one woman said at a forum in Kumasi. “But we mention polygamy—something our grandfathers practiced—and suddenly we’re backwards? Make it make sense.”
It’s not about being anti-West. It’s about the double standard. About feeling ashamed of your own culture while trying to fit into someone else’s.
When It Actually Works
Amina and her co-wife share a compound in Tamale. They share cooking duties. They share childcare. They share a husband who, according to them, treats them both fairly.
“She’s not my competition,” Amina says, laughing. “She’s my sister. When I’m tired, she takes over. When she needs help, I’m there. Our husband doesn’t sneak around. Everything is open.”
The health workers have noticed something: in stable polygamous homes with clear rules and honest communication, STI rates are actually lower. Everyone knows who’s sleeping with whom. There are no surprises. No infections appearing out of nowhere.
The children in these homes often describe feeling like they have extra mothers, not divided ones.
But—and this is crucial—this only works when everyone has genuinely agreed. When there’s respect. When the man can actually afford to take care of two families.
When It Destroys
Let’s not romanticize this.
Plenty of women have watched their husband bring home a second wife and felt their world shatter. Felt abandoned. Replaced. Forced to smile and accept what tears them apart inside because “tradition” demands it.
Plenty of men have bankrupted themselves trying to maintain two households on one salary, leaving everyone miserable and broke.
“Polygamy isn’t some magic solution to infidelity,” says a marriage counselor in Accra. “It only works when nobody’s being forced. When there’s real consent, real resources, real maturity. Otherwise? You’re just multiplying the pain.”
Some women stay in polygamous marriages not out of choice but out of fear—fear of being alone, fear of losing their children, fear of what people will say.
That’s not liberation. That’s survival.
So What’s the Answer? Nobody knows. That’s the honest truth.
Is it better to have one wife and three secret girlfriends? Or two wives and complete transparency?
Is it better to maintain a Western ideal of monogamy that many aren’t actually practicing? Or embrace a traditional system that can either nurture or devastate?
The continent is changing. Young professionals in Accra are having conversations their parents never had. Rural communities are questioning practices their grandparents never questioned.
Maybe the real question isn’t whether polygamy is good or bad. Maybe it’s: What are we actually doing to protect families from lies, diseases, and broken trust?
Because right now, whether we admit it or not, a lot of marriages are already polygamous. They’re just not honest about it.
And the dishonesty—the secrets, the infections, the betrayals discovered through text messages and lipstick stains—that’s what’s really destroying homes.
So Africa stands here, caught between the old ways and new realities, between what we say we believe and what we actually do, between public morality and private truth.
The debate continues. In taxis. In churches. In bedrooms at 2 AM when someone can’t sleep because they found their spouse’s second phone.
Is polygamy the answer?
Maybe. Maybe not.
But at least now, people are brave enough to ask the question out loud.
About the Author
